*sigh* Dogma Is Good for Mental Health

A new study of the language habits related to depression reveals that happiness is a reward for the small-minded and unjustifiably assured.

A recent study made an investigation into possible indicators of depression by identifying the different language habits of the depressed in contrast to the mentally and emotionally well-adjusted. One of their main findings was that the latter are far more likely to speak confidently in certainties and absolutes.

“Absolutist words”—which convey absolute magnitudes or probabilities, such as “always”, “nothing” or “completely”—were found to be better markers for mental health forums than either pronouns or negative emotion words.

This phenomena seems related to studies which suggest that religious people are generally happier than others. True belief and blind faith can go a long way in glossing over the doubt and unease experienced by those unable or unwilling to live based upon such simplistic assumptions. But since Tibetan monks, who practice uncertainty daily, are probably actually happier than Southern Baptists, I wonder if this is not a sort of backwards view.

In a monastery everyone is a monk, so nobody has to deal with anybodies certainties or absolutism. In western culture those who attempt to break down dogmas and other compulsive norms are often restrained by those who cling to them. So perhaps it is not a lack of certainty or absolutes that is connected to depression, but is instead a reaction to the certainties and absolutes of others they are forced to endure day in and day out.

Think about that. Those who have taken the humble position that any absolute truths are likely unknowable are surrounded by those who are maddening sure of everything; as well an entire society based upon the decisions made by the absolutists. In this way one might get the idea that depression is a completely reasonable response to the conditions created by True Belief in their environment.

At the same time we might also question how genuine the happiness of absolutists is. Is it a deeply felt experience, or is it just so enmeshed in their scripts that they are able to convince observers and their selves that they are happy and well-adjusted based on the operating assumption that reports of experience are objectively equivalent to actual experiences?

The big question here is, given that this is a reliable theory of depression, how do we deal with it? Do we de-dogmatize the masses to fit the wisdom of the few, or do we attempt to indoctrinate the few and then alienate those unable to conform? The latter seems to be the usual outcome of modern civilization, so perhaps our best hope for assuring human happiness is to eradicate absolutism and certainty to the best of our ability. But where do we start?

I don’t know. *sigh*

4 thoughts on “*sigh* Dogma Is Good for Mental Health

  1. Absolutely! Let’s change the narrative and break out of this stale, putrid, anachronistic consensus reality! It feels a little like the consensus is quite literally falling apart and something is forming in the collective unconscious. It is not apparent what it is yet, but there is a reformation and restructuring happening.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, it does seem we are entering some event horizon, based on a number of different factors over a large spectrum of subjects. Of course, the thing about being in it is you never know when the omega point has been crossed. It is only later we see *that moment when*. In real time it tends to feel more like *wtf is happening here?!?*. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I don’t know if you’ve ever read William Irwin Thompson, but I think you would really appreciate his brilliance. Damn if I can’t find the books now (I’ve been moving and everything is in boxes) but his book “Darkness and Scattered Light” is a masterpiece that portends the times we are living in. I can’t even put into words how prescient what he writes is for the times we are living in now. Damn! I’ve got three of his books but they are all in a box somewhere…. I posted this awhile back. Don’t know if you saw it or not. It’s something I quoted from one of his books long ago, and reposted.

    “To take a step into the future we need to shift our weight to the opposite foot; to think about the future we also need to shift the emphasis to the opposite hemisphere of the brain. The way for a technological society to take a step into the future is to shift the weight of its emphasis from machines to myth.”

    William Irwin Thompson “Darkness and Scattered Light”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. How can you go wrong when born unto the initials ‘WIT’! 🙂

      I have not read him. Bookstore life, stacks everywhere, where the fuck am I at again?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s